Audit Finding
OpenWrong tax treatment
ChatGPT

Federal Module -- Gifted Property Holding Period -- Wrong tax treatment

The Claim
ChatGPT told a user that a daughter who received a gifted mobile home must hold the property for more than one year to qualify for long-term capital gain treatment, and that she could claim a loss if she sold it for less than the fair market value on the date of the gift.
ChatGPT incorrectly ignored the tacking rule under IRC §1223(2), which requires the donee's holding period to include the donor's holding period for gifted property — meaning the daughter already qualified for long-term treatment without holding the property an additional year. ChatGPT also incorrectly stated a loss was available based on the date-of-death FMV; under IRC §1015(a), the basis for loss on gifted property is the lower of the donor's adjusted basis or the FMV at the date of the gift, not the FMV at the date of sale, and no deductible loss arises when the sale price falls between those two figures.
IRC §1223(2) (tacking of holding period for gifted property); IRC §1015(a) (basis of property acquired by gift — loss basis rule); IRS Publication 551 (Basis of Assets)
A small business owner or individual who relies on ChatGPT's advice could unnecessarily delay selling gifted property waiting for a one-year holding period that has already been met, or could incorrectly claim a capital loss deduction that is disallowed under the dual-basis loss rule, triggering an IRS audit, accuracy-related penalties under IRC §6662, and potential back taxes with interest.
Verdict
KKATC Tax Response
Note
Sourced from reddit candidate: https://news.bloombergtax.com/tax-insights-and-commentary/chatgpt-can-give-tax-advice-but-you-really-get-what-you-pay-for
Share This Entry
AI tax error documented by @KKATCOfficial Audit Watchdog: Wrong tax treatment -- IRC §1223(2) (tacking of holding period for gifted property); IRC §1015(a) (basis of property acquired by gift — loss basis rule); IRS Publication 551 (Basis of Assets). Full record: https://www.kkatc.com/watchdog/chatgpt/chatgpt-told-a-user-that-a #IRSCode #SmallBusiness #TaxCompliance #AIAccountability #AuditWatchdog #KKATC #ChatGPT #OpenAI
Share on X →
KKATC Tax Prep and Consulting
This scenario is covered.
If AI gave you advice like this, a review costs less than the penalty. Twelve years of Fortune-level corporate tax experience.
Book a Consultation →